Wednesday, April 3, 2024

Credentialing, Not Correcting: The CDC’s self-reform effort is unlikely to succeed in restoring public trust

By Carl Schramm. 

"American institutions’ response to the Covid pandemic is an example of what Roger Koppl called “expert failure.” Many Americans feared the virus, especially in its early stages, and welcomed informed advice on how to avoid infection. The federal Centers for Disease Control sought to offer such expertise but failed, insisting more on its presumed authority than on the truth. The public subsequently lost faith in the agency.

We now know, of course, that much of the CDC’s pandemic-era guidance had little scientific basis and brought devastating consequences for ordinary Americans. Masking, social distancing, and sanitizing grocery carts did little or nothing to stop the spread of the virus and imposed huge social costs. Similarly, extended school closures, which the CDC recommended in part to satisfy the nation’s teachers’ unions, were a shameful and tremendously costly decision, based on shoddy science. Indeed, children were the least likely of all demographic groups to acquire or transmit the Covid virus.

The CDC not only imposed spurious guidance but also vigorously resisted advice from nongovernment experts on how to reduce the virus’s spread and potential death toll. Discovery in the case of Murthy v. Missouri, now pending at the Supreme Court, reveals how highly placed federal officials, including Anthony Fauci, allegedly attempted to destroy the careers of the civilian scientists who authored the Great Barrington Declaration. The declaration, an open letter released in October 2020, counseled the CDC to reject its initial approach of seeking to protect the entire population and instead focus on protecting the over-65 population. While such a response would likely have saved more lives than the CDC’s methodology, social-media companies at the advice of the White House suppressed some of the declaration authors’ content, damaging their careers and reputations. Indeed, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals last October enjoined the Biden administration from “coerc[ing] or significantly encourag[ing] social-media companies to remove, delete, suppress, or reduce, including through altering their algorithms, posted social-media content containing protected free speech.”

The CDC’s failure to provide reliable and unbiased expert direction, and the agency’s repeated dishonesty and corruption, led to collapsing trust in the public-health establishment. Indeed, some surveys suggest that over half of the population would not trust the CDC in the future. And despite the Biden administration’s continued efforts to promote vaccine uptake, most Americans have chosen to ignore government efforts to reduce what officials believe is the virus’s possible resurgence. Only about 20 percent of Americans are fully vaccinated against Covid, according to CDC statistics as of mid-February, and fully 70 percent of Americans in a recent survey reported being very unlikely to get, or uncertain about getting, the vaccine.

The agency knows that it has lost public trust, and it has two efforts underway to restore its reputation. First, the CDC has sought to identify more nascent communicable diseases as having the potential to become pandemics. Consider, for example, the CDC’s recent efforts to make monkeypox a national issue, and the outsize media attention paid to a handful of new polio, measles, tuberculosis, and leprosy cases. This posture makes the agency appear to be communicating dangers earlier than it did during Covid. And, recalling the central role it played in the nation’s consciousness during the Covid pandemic, the agency apparently believes that it can leverage public fear to revive its authority.

In such efforts, however, the agency and the public-health establishment are reverting to ideological habits that previously squandered the public’s trust. Prominent public-health experts have hardly discussed these illnesses in the context of the 8 million illegals who have entered this country on the Biden administration’s watch without being examined for communicable diseases. Epidemiologists in both government and academia have stood largely silent as millions of “newcomers” illegally enter the United States uninoculated for diseases that, in the blink of an eye, could become American pandemics.

The agency’s second move to regain public trust, a supposedly thoroughgoing self-directed reform effort, is hardly more compelling than the first. Over the past four budgets, the White House has approved more than $725 million for the CDC’s “data modernization” project, apparently the focus of its internal reforms. One might ask why the CDC’s data need “modernizing.” Consider that in 2024, the agency boasted on its website that it would soon have its first-ever public-health data strategy—after it finished organizing the newly created Office of Public Health Data, Surveillance and Technology. Shouldn’t these have been long-standing areas of interest and competency for an organization tasked with monitoring the health of Americans? Was the agency waiting for Covid before it could step into the modern world? What does this say about the agency’s culture? Perhaps it demonstrates that the CDC considers experts, rather than data, the most effective tool to monitor the public’s health.

The nation awaits the results of the CDC’s two-year reform plan, “Moving Forward.” Given how the agency handled the pandemic and how it’s conducting its supposed reforms, there’s reason to fear that the CDC is more interested in credentialing new experts than conducting objective research. And if that suspicion proves out, then the CDC can forget about regaining the public trust."

Tuesday, April 2, 2024

Can We Power the EPA’s EV Fantasy?

The overhaul of electrical grids and distribution would require labor and resources we don’t have.

By Jonathan A. Lesser and Mark P. Mills. Mr. Lesser is a senior fellow and Mr. Mills director of the National Center for Energy Analytics. Excerpts:

"The EPA admits it can be met only if EVs compose well above half of new vehicle sales by 2032." (the agency’s new standard for carbon-dioxide emissions)

"Electric cars accounted for shy of 8% of new auto sales last year and drained billions from automakers’ profits."

"There is, however, another wild card in the EPA’s gamble. Widespread adoption of EVs will require an unprecedented and staggeringly expensive expansion of local electrical grids. This will require a huge increase in the production of electrical transformers, along with more power plants and transmission lines to produce and deliver energy.

This overhaul must include upgrading local grid distribution at the roughly 3,000 electric utilities across the country—the wires, poles and transformers that line our streets. There are 60 million to 80 million distribution transformers in neighborhoods, designed for existing loads. Around one million new ones are sold annually, two-thirds of which replace aged-out transformers. That replacement rate isn’t close to meeting the EPA’s dreams. Millions more—and heavier—transformers will be needed to handle higher power levels and more frequent use, even if many EVs are charged overnight. This will also require replacing many of the existing utility poles to handle new transformers’ extra weight."

"millions of homes and apartment complexes will need electrical upgrades to accommodate at-home chargers."

"Electricians will need to install new circuits for EV chargers, and many older homes will need new power panels to handle increased demand."

"Replicating the nation’s some 195,000 retail gasoline stations will require far more than the 4,000 charging facilities that the Federal Highway Administration has proposed. Given the physics of electricity, thousands of these charging stations will each have the power demand of an entire town rather than that of a typical convenience store."

"One Energy Department study estimated some $50 billion to $125 billion in infrastructure upgrades will be needed to support EVs composing 10% of all on-road cars. Today they amount to less than 2%. We estimate that achieving the EPA’s goal will require north of $1 trillion in grid upgrades by 2035."

"Delivery of the largest utility transformers can already take several years, and overall transformer costs have risen 70% since 2018. Replacing tens of millions of distribution transformers would require massive quantities of copper, most of which would have to be imported. The process would also exceed the production capabilities of the handful of American manufacturers."

"The unique electrical steel needed for transformers and electric motors is also in short supply, served by only one major producer, Cleveland Cliffs. New Energy Department rules to improve transformer efficiency will require switching to even more specialized and costlier amorphous steel."

A Lesson in DEI Failure From Britain

‘Diversity, equity and inclusion’ costs billions and doesn’t work.

WSJ editorial. 

"Memo to companies: Go ahead and cancel your DEI programs. That’s more or less the message of a recent report commissioned by the U.K. government finding that diversity, equity and inclusion in the workplace isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

The report, presented to Business and Trade Secretary Kemi Badenoch by an independent panel, found there’s little evidence DEI efforts such as mandatory antibias training and corporate policy overhauls have any positive effect on corporate culture.

“Causality between interventions and outcomes is often near impossible to discern, even if positive correlations should be taken seriously,” the authors write. “Definitive claims of ‘what works’ can be misleading or inconclusive. Results in one context cannot necessarily be replicated in another as workplaces are complex social environments with countless variables.”

It’s hard to say what DEI even means: “The terms ‘diversity,’ ‘inclusion’ (and other associated terminology) are conceptually ambiguous, rapidly evolving, and often conflated,” the authors note. They point out that while the fad is to focus on diversity along racial, sex or other visible lines, “a visibly diverse organization is not necessarily meaningfully heterogenous.” Viewpoint diversity may be more important for a thriving company.

Despite this lack of results, DEI has become a huge and expensive business. U.S. companies spend some $8 billion a year on DEI training, the British report notes, and in the five years to 2020 the number of people with the job title “head of diversity” more than doubled on the professional networking site LinkedIn. U.K. taxpayers spend £557 million a year on 10,000 government jobs related to DEI.

A negative twist is that in the U.K. companies face growing risks of having to pay again for DEI as a legal backlash gathers momentum. Several employment-law cases have found that employers, including the government, violated British protections on freedom of belief by punishing employees who dissented from the DEI orthodoxy on race or transgenderism.

This is no way to run a company, a government or an economy—on either side of the Atlantic. Companies profit from diverse and inclusive workplaces, but that’s often the opposite of what DEI programs produce. Kudos to the British for starting to rethink this divisive politically motivated scheme."

Monday, April 1, 2024

McKinsey’s Diversity Matters/Delivers/Wins Results Revisited

By Jeremiah Green and John R. M. Hand. 

"Abstract

In a series of very influential studies, McKinsey (2015; 2018; 2020; 2023) reports finding statistically significant positive relations between the industry-adjusted earnings before interest and taxes margins of global McKinsey-chosen sets of large public firms and the racial/ethnic diversity of their executives. However, when we revisit McKinsey’s tests using data for firms in the publicly observable S&P 500® as of 12/31/2019, we do not find statistically significant relations between McKinsey’s inverse normalized Herfindahl-Hirschman measures of executive racial/ethnic diversity at mid-2020 and either industry-adjusted earnings before interest and taxes margin or industry-adjusted sales growth, gross margin, return on assets, return on equity, and total shareholder return over the prior five years 2015–2019. Combined with the erroneous reverse-causality nature of McKinsey’s tests, our inability to quasi-replicate their results suggests that despite the imprimatur given to McKinsey’s studies, they should not be relied on to support the view that US publicly traded firms can expect to deliver improved financial performance if they increase the racial/ethnic diversity of their executives."

Capitalism and Labor Shares: A Cross-Country Panel Study

By Andrew T. Young & Robert Lawson. European Journal of Political Economy.

"Abstract

We examine the empirical relationship between the institutions of economic freedom and labor shares in a panel up to 93 countries covering 1970 through 2009. We find that a standard deviation increase in the Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World (EFW) score is associated about 1/3 standard deviation increase in a country’s labor share. Starting from the sample mean labor share in our panel, this amounts to about 4.26 percentage points. This relationship is robust to considering OECD and non-OECD samples separately. It is also (both qualitatively and quantitatively) robust to controlling for differences in human capital levels, labor productivity, trade union density, and international economic flows. Breaking the EFW into its individual component areas, the regulation of credit, business and labor appears to be the most important source of the positive EFW-labor share relationship.

Keywords: labor share, income shares, economic freedom, political economy, democracy, capitalism, institutions, distribution of income"

The Coming Electricity Crisis

Artificial-intelligence data centers and climate rules are pushing the power grid to what could become a breaking point.

WSJ Editorial. 

"President Biden and the press keep raising alarms about a climate crisis that his policies can’t do much about. Yet in the meantime they’re ignoring how government climate policies are contributing to a looming electric-grid crisis that is more urgent and could be avoided.

These pages have been warning for years about an electric-power shortage. And now grid regulators and utilities are ramping up warnings. Projections for U.S. electricity demand growth over the next five years have doubled from a year ago. The major culprits: New artificial-intelligence data centers, federally subsidized manufacturing plants, and the government-driven electric-vehicle transition.

***

Georgia Power recently increased 17-fold its winter power demand forecast by 2031, citing growth in new industries such as EV and battery factories. AEP Ohio says new data centers and Intel’s $20 billion planned chip plant will increase strain on the grid. Chip factories and data centers can consume 100 times more power than a typical industrial business.

PJM Interconnection, which operates the wholesale power market across 13 Midwest and Northeast states, this year doubled its 15-year annual forecast for demand growth. Its projected power demand in the region for 2029 has increased by about 10 gigawatts—about twice as much as New York City uses on a typical day.

Don’t expect the power to come from New York, which is marching toward a power shortage as it shuts down nuclear and fossil-fuel power in favor of wind and solar. A new Micron chip factory in upstate New York is expected to require as much power by the 2040s as the states of New Hampshire and Vermont combined.

Electricity demand to power data centers is projected to increase by 13% to 15% compounded annually through 2030. Yet a shortage of power is already delaying new data centers by two to six years, according to commercial-real estate firm

. It is also driving Big Tech companies into the energy business. this month struck a $650 million deal to buy a data center in Pennsylvania powered by an on-site 2.5 gigawatt nuclear plant.

Data centers—like manufacturing plants—require reliable power around the clock year-round, which wind and solar don’t provide. Businesses can’t afford to wait for batteries to become cost-effective. Building transmission lines to connect distant renewables to the grid typically takes 10 to 12 years.

Because of these challenges, Obama Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz last week predicted that utilities will ultimately have to rely more on gas, coal and nuclear plants to support surging demand. “We’re not going to build 100 gigawatts of new renewables in a few years,” he said. No kidding.

The problem is that utilities are rapidly retiring fossil-fuel and nuclear plants. “We are subtracting dispatchable [fossil fuel] resources at a pace that’s not sustainable, and we can’t build dispatchable resources to replace the dispatchable resources we’re shutting down,” Federal Energy Regulatory Commissioner Mark Christie warned this month.

About 20 gigawatts of fossil-fuel power are scheduled to retire over the next two years—enough to power 15 million homes—including a large natural-gas plant in Massachusetts that serves as a crucial source of electricity in cold snaps. PJM’s external market monitor last week warned that up to 30% of the region’s installed capacity is at risk of retiring by 2030.

Some plants are nearing the end of their useful life-spans, but an onslaught of costly regulation is the bigger cause. A soon-to-be-finalized Environmental Protection Agency rule would require natural-gas plants to install expensive and unproven carbon capture technology.

The PJM report cites “the role of states and the federal government in subsidizing resources and in environmental regulation.” It added: “The simple fact is that the sources of new capacity that could fully replace the retiring capacity have not been clearly identified.”

Meantime, the Inflation Reduction Act’s huge renewable subsidies make it harder for fossil-fuel and nuclear plants to compete in wholesale power markets. The cost of producing power from solar and wind is roughly the same as from natural gas. But IRA tax credits can offset up to 50% of the cost of renewable operators.

Baseload plants can’t turn a profit operating only when needed to back up renewables, so they are closing. This was the main culprit for Texas’s week-long power outage in February 2021 and the eastern U.S.’s rolling blackouts during Christmas 2022.

The media will discover this problem eventually, though not this year if it might call into question Mr. Biden’s climate agenda. Perhaps they’ll notice when more blackouts arrive."

Buy American, Build Nothing

The infrastructure law of 2021 makes it hard to build anything.

By Judge Glock. 

"The Bipartisan Infrastructure Law of 2021 is reshaping how America builds—but not in the way its supporters hoped. Few big projects have been completed, and one little-noted aspect of the law, expanding mandates to use American-made products, has confused federal, state and local governments, and created new levels of bureaucratic waste.

Since the 1970s the Buy America program has required that federally funded transportation projects use steel, iron and manufactured goods made in the U.S. But the new version—Build America, Buy America, adorably called BABA for short—added to the all-American list construction materials and specific products such as glass, lumber and drywall while tightening oversight of the program.

The new law also expanded Buy America requirements far beyond transportation to include all infrastructure funded by the federal government. As with many mandates during the Biden administration, the law defined the terms as broadly as possible, with “infrastructure” including “at a minimum” not only roads, dams and airports, but utilities, broadband and even individual buildings.

Government agencies are scrambling to find out how to comply with its impossible burdens. The Education Department found 32 separate programs that would be classified as infrastructure under the law. The Federal Emergency Management Agency found 23 programs.

The law formally created a Made in America Office to review agency compliance and approve waivers. Considering the extent of the mandates, this has been difficult. The law put that office in charge of policing individual government purchases for domestic content. This has wrapped federal officers in minutiae. The Transportation Security Administration had to get a waiver to order “tactical pants” for air marshals. The Department of Veterans Affairs and other departments had to get a waiver to buy pills for the treatment of HIV. The Environmental Protection Agency got a waiver so that the North Unit Irrigation District of Madras, Ore., could use reinforced polyethylene liner for a canal when there were no U.S. producers for this niche product.

All the mandates, waivers, and box-checking add time and cost to government purchases. The law itself says BABA can increase costs by up to 25% on the entirety of a project. But according to some studies, products subject to Buy America requirements can easily cost more. The Federal Highway Administration, which already had to adhere to the old Buy America law, this month estimated that some of the new BABA requirements could cost more than $700 million a year to implement, although the agency admitted it didn’t calculate the expense of compliance and delays.

America’s critical defense and national security products should be made at home. But pants and drywall don’t have to be. Because of BABA, the infrastructure law has made building in the U.S. harder than ever.

Mr. Glock is director of research at the Manhattan Institute and author of “The Dead Pledge: The Origins of the Mortgage Market and Federal Bailouts, 1913-1939.”"