Evaluating the free market by comparing it to the alternatives (We don't need more regulations, We don't need more price controls, No Socialism in the courtroom, Hey, White House, leave us all alone)
Trade isn’t complicated. People around the world work to produce things for one another—and protectionism makes that cooperation harder.
By Scott A. Burns & Caleb S. Fuller of The Independent Institute.
"Paul Krugman once said: “If there were an Economist’s Creed, it would surely contain the affirmations ‘I understand comparative advantage’ and ‘I advocate Free Trade.’”
We agree. Alas, economists have a nasty habit of overcomplicating the virtues of trade when we communicate with the public. That is why we propose that our fellow economists adopt a new creed when we talk trade with the public: “KISS: Keep It Simple, Stupid.”
Edwin Cannan, a professor at the London School of Economics and president of the Royal Economic Society, gave a prescient 1933 address titled “The Need for a Simpler Economics.”
Delivered almost a century ago, Cannan’s words feel evergreen in an age of sword-rattling against trade. Here is a sample of his simple points.
First, people reverse the logic of bargaining when they begin thinking of “nations,” instead of “individuals.” In our everyday exchanges, we all want to get as much as we can with the least sacrifice. Some might even call this “the art of the deal!” But in international trade, people’s rhetoric shifts, as if the objective were to “give, and not to get”: to produce and export (give) as much as we can while importing (get) as little as possible. That anti-import sentiment is the essence of mercantilism, the very doctrine Adam Smith set out to dismantle 250 years ago when he penned The Wealth of Nations.
If you slip into this first fallacy, you will inevitably fall into a second: treating cheap imports as bad news. In everyday life, it seems obvious that we are better off if we can sell our exports for very high prices and buy our imports at very low prices. We want to sell our output for a high price, and we hope to find “Always Low Prices” when we stroll through the sliding doors at Walmart. Protectionism teaches us to lament in foreign trade what we celebrate at our local checkout counter: low prices. American consumers rarely complain when domestic companies offer Black Friday or Cyber Monday discounts. So why should they object when foreign sellers do the same?
It follows from this second point that foreign subsidies are not inherently injurious to us. For a government to subsidize, it must first tax. Suppose a foreign power taxes its own people, then subsidizes some domestic industry that, in turn, sells us cheaper goods. In effect, these foreign governments are taxing their citizens to sell cheaper goods to ours.
According to Cannan, people suffer from similar fallacies when it comes to trade’s influence on jobs. The man on the street thinks that exports giveth jobs and imports taketh away. But jobs are a means to an end. We work to earn income so that we can spend it on food, shelter, and clothing. If trade brings us more stuff for less labor, that is cause for celebration, not concern. Trade changes the composition of jobs, true; but it does not permanently increase unemployment. If it did, our unemployment rate would be at record highs after decades of globalization, not near historic lows.
Reading Cannan inspired us to put our new “creed” into practice. If we had just one moment to convince skeptics of the virtues of free trade, we would try our own hand at a “simpler economics” by asking protectionists why they want to stop the rest of the world from working for us.
Surely, President Trump himself grasps the value of specialization and exchange—at least in his personal life. Mar-a-Lago hardly runs itself, and we highly doubt Trump sets his own tables, maintains his own china (no pun intended), or mows the lawn.
Now zoom out and look at the planet as a whole. Imagine a Martian peering through his telescope. He would notice billions of little humans scurrying around, doing tasks. Some people would be working to satisfy themselves directly, such as the person in Brooklyn pouring himself a cup of morning coffee. But what would be striking is the enormous number of tasks performed to satisfy other people’s desires, including strangers across an ocean. That woman sitting down at her desk to refine a German engine is perfecting a new car that will be sold to an American businessman in five years. That man directing a crane in the Port of Tokyo is placing boxes on ships that will bring joy to American buyers in a few weeks.
If you asked our Martian to draw some conclusions, he would probably find the international division of labor a pretty sweet deal for both foreigners and Americans. We do too.
Think of it this way: Each side of the ocean works for the other while the other is asleep. While you were sleeping, countless people on the other side of the globe toiled away on products you will soon enjoy, letting the dollars you earn stretch much further. You will have a chance to do the same for them when you wake up. Isn’t that the dream? To have people working to meet your needs while you… sleep? Yet that is precisely what free trade makes available to each of us.
Protectionism, in contrast, makes that work grind to a halt when the lights go out. There is no planet—ours or the Martian’s—where that is a path to prosperity.
These themes are explored further in the authors’ forthcoming book from the Independent Institute. Trade Wars: Why Freedom Trumps Tariffs."
Editorial from National Review. Excerpts:
"the FAA’s telecommunications network suddenly failed, apparently caused by a faulty update to its decades-old tangle of copper wiring."
"the FAA’s antiquated infrastructure isn’t a partisan issue. It’s the institutional consequence of having an unaccountable bureaucracy manage the skies.
"Unlike almost every other major country, the U.S. federal government funds and operates air traffic control directly. Congress must appropriate its budget each year, and controllers must work without pay when the government shuts down. Infrastructure investments are subject to political timetables. Meanwhile, the FAA is expected to regulate the very system that it runs."
the FAA received $12.5 billion from last year’s reconciliation law for that purpose (Infrastructure upgrades). Earlier this month, it requested $30 billion more. Now, Duffy claims that he really needs $50 billion to get the job done. And we thought airlines’ add-on fees were bad."
"Improvements don’t have to be so costly. The FAA has spent a quarter century trying to switch its network from copper wires to fiber-optic cables. Its counterpart up north, , completed most of the same transition in just 18 months.
The fundamental difference? Nav Canada was spun off from the national government in 1996 as a nonprofit corporation. The organization is funded entirely by user fees from the airlines and private aircraft that rely on its systems, not general taxes, and it’s structured to be accountable to both private stakeholders and the government. When it needs to finance capital projects, Nav Canada doesn’t have to wait for approval. It can simply issue bonds and recoup the cost over the long run."
"privatization lowered costs and boosted productivity for the aviation sector, especially compared with the FAA. Safety has greatly improved, and Nav Canada leads in technological advancement. Dozens of countries have since followed Canada’s lead toward an independent, commercial operator."
"Seattle’s minimum-wage experience with food delivery offers even clearer causal evidence. A 2025 NBER working paper comparing Seattle delivery workers with those elsewhere in Washington found that the city’s task-level minimum-pay rule doubled average base pay per task. But lower tips erased more than a third of that gain, while highly active workers completed fewer monthly tasks. The result was no increase in their overall monthly earnings.
Unpaid idle time also increased, as did distances driven between tasks. The NBER authors attributed this outcome to free entry into the labor market: higher per-task pay attracted more workers, leaving more of them competing for a limited pool of deliveries. Workers consequently completed fewer tasks and spent more unpaid time waiting between them, offsetting the gains from higher per-task pay."
"Despite regular reminders that wealth taxes are generally unpopular, such measures always seem in vogue. California wealth-tax advocates are already plotting a 2028 do-over, and with large majorities in Congress after January, Democrats are likely to push for similar proposals federally. Economists like me spend much of our time explaining how wealth taxes hurt employers, drive out investment and raise little revenue. But the absurd things people do to avoid them can be even more revealing.
France repealed its annual net wealth tax in 2017 after the prime minister concluded that it had driven 10,000 people with 35 billion euros’ ($39.3 billion) worth of assets out of the country. The exodus shrank the overall tax base and caused the government to lose revenue, according to one analysis. California didn’t even need to pass its version to get the same result. Because the measure was based on where a billionaire lived on Jan. 1, nearly 30 percent of the projected wealth tax base left before the vote, and the income taxes those people would have paid left with them."
See National Democrats flock to Denver for a reality check — and a preview for the future by Seth Klamann of The Denver Post. Excerpt:
"In a Friday speech, Massachusetts U.S. Rep. Jake Auchincloss, who chairs Majority Democrats, said the group stood with “the majority alarmed by the extremes.” He criticized inclusionary zoning and rent control, defended natural gas and nuclear power, and backed a “supply-and-demand”-based approach to the economy.
“My challenge to everyone running in 2028, which might also be every person in this room, is (to) tell us which ideas you’ll stop giving permission to, the ones that defy common sense or don’t work,” he said. “Tell us which privileges you’ll confront, even if your donors and allies object. Tell us which opportunities you’ll promote so every child can share in the American promise.”"
More from a tweet by Reily Connaughton. He is a senior advisor to the governor of Rhode Island.
"Supply and demand is a fact of reality, and the fact is when supply goes down prices go up. That means you can’t lower prices by stopping things from being built."
"Banning natural gas or nuclear power ignores the pain of high energy prices - it drives utility bills higher. Rent control or exclusionary zoning don’t lower costs or build wealth, they make housing more expensive for the middle class."
"Those who insisted that we keep our schools closed during the pandemic are now trying to cancel honors classes in the name of equity. First they held students back by closing the classrooms. Now they’re canceling classes that help students get ahead."
By Christopher Sharp, Caleb Jacobs & Ryan Prenosil of The Cicero Institute. Excerpt:
"Advocates argue that ending homelessness requires more federal funding, citing rising rents and a workforce they characterize as “woefully underpaid.”1 The National Alliance to End Homelessness’s 2023 report “New Estimates Suggest that $4.8 Billion Is Needed to Bring Homeless Services Salaries into the Modern Era” advocated for an additional $9.6 billion in federal appropriations supporting the Continuum of Care Program, including $4.8 billion specifically to raise homeless service worker salaries.2
An examination of a balanced panel of 1,458 nonprofit Continuum of Care (CoC) providers shows that program budgets for compensation have increased significantly. Reported financials in both 2013 and 2024 show total compensation grew 117.8 percent and total revenue grew 123.9 percent, dramatically outpacing the 34.7 percent cumulative inflation rate and the 30.7 percent growth in the national Point-in-Time (PIT) homelessness count.3
Growth in the homelessness sector was not concentrated in a few outliers: 84 percent of providers grew compensation faster than inflation, 54 percent more than doubled it, and 29 percent more than tripled it.4 Provider compensation also grew roughly 2.7 times faster than the broader nonprofit sector benchmark on an annualized basis.5 The problem is not how money flows into the CoC system, as the National Alliance to End Homelessness’s report suggests. The problem is that the system pays for inputs (beds, salaries, services delivered) rather than for outcomes (people exiting homelessness for unsubsidized housing, employment, and treatment success). Compensation tracks revenue at a stable 36–39 percent of total income across the period, meaning the entire industry has grown together while measured outcomes have not moved.
These findings support a federal course correction, which is already underway. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) FY 2026 Continuum of Care Competition Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO), released in 2026, operationalizes Executive Order 143217 by declaring that “Housing First has been a profound failure,” making 40 percent of renewal funding fully competitive based on merit between communities, setting aside $1.3 billion for transitional housing and supportive services, and scoring providers on reductions in unsheltered homelessness, treatment, employment income, and exits to unsubsidized housing rather than the number of beds funded. This report supplies the empirical case for that reorientation, drawn from the providers’ own IRS Form 990 filings.
The data clearly shows that the solution is not more dollars spent, but rather a programmatic change that prioritizes incentives. The FY 2026 NOFO’s pivot to scoring outcomes, competing renewals, and rebalancing toward services is the right method for rewarding value and performance in homelessness assistance."