Saturday, November 14, 2026

The Case for Pay-for-Value in Federal Homelessness Funding

By Christopher Sharp, Caleb Jacobs & Ryan Prenosil of The Cicero Institute. Excerpt:

"Advocates argue that ending homelessness requires more federal funding, citing rising rents and a workforce they characterize as “woefully underpaid.”1 The National Alliance to End Homelessness’s 2023 report “New Estimates Suggest that $4.8 Billion Is Needed to Bring Homeless Services Salaries into the Modern Era” advocated for an additional $9.6 billion in federal appropriations supporting the Continuum of Care Program, including $4.8 billion specifically to raise homeless service worker salaries.2

An examination of a balanced panel of 1,458 nonprofit Continuum of Care (CoC) providers shows that program budgets for compensation have increased significantly. Reported financials in both 2013 and 2024 show total compensation grew 117.8 percent and total revenue grew 123.9 percent, dramatically outpacing the 34.7 percent cumulative inflation rate and the 30.7 percent growth in the national Point-in-Time (PIT) homelessness count.3

Growth in the homelessness sector was not concentrated in a few outliers: 84 percent of providers grew compensation faster than inflation, 54 percent more than doubled it, and 29 percent more than tripled it.4 Provider compensation also grew roughly 2.7 times faster than the broader nonprofit sector benchmark on an annualized basis.5 The problem is not how money flows into the CoC system, as the National Alliance to End Homelessness’s report suggests. The problem is that the system pays for inputs (beds, salaries, services delivered) rather than for outcomes (people exiting homelessness for unsubsidized housing, employment, and treatment success). Compensation tracks revenue at a stable 36–39 percent of total income across the period, meaning the entire industry has grown together while measured outcomes have not moved.

These findings support a federal course correction, which is already underway. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s (HUD) FY 2026 Continuum of Care Competition Notice of Funding Opportunity (NOFO), released in 2026, operationalizes Executive Order 143217 by declaring that “Housing First has been a profound failure,” making 40 percent of renewal funding fully competitive based on merit between communities, setting aside $1.3 billion for transitional housing and supportive services, and scoring providers on reductions in unsheltered homelessness, treatment, employment income, and exits to unsubsidized housing rather than the number of beds funded. This report supplies the empirical case for that reorientation, drawn from the providers’ own IRS Form 990 filings.
The data clearly shows that the solution is not more dollars spent, but rather a programmatic change that prioritizes incentives. The FY 2026 NOFO’s pivot to scoring outcomes, competing renewals, and rebalancing toward services is the right method for rewarding value and performance in homelessness assistance."

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.