My Chronicle of Higher Education letter on Thaler and Sunstein

See I Think, Therefore I Grow.

"June 06, 2008 Premium 

 

To the Editor:

I enjoyed Evan R. Goldstein's "The New Paternalism" (The Chronicle Review, May 9) about Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein, authors of Nudge. Who could disagree that "human perception is flawed," or that we all have "cognitive limitations"? This suggests enacting policies that "nudge" people in the right direction.

But it seems like a straw man is being used when Thaler and Sunstein say that policy makers previously assumed that all people can think like Albert Einstein and can exercise the patience of Mahatma Gandhi. Surely no neoclassical economist would believe that. Even Milton Friedman, in Capitalism and Freedom, said that "there is no avoiding the need for some measure of paternalism." But he also said that the principle that "some shall decide for others" is very troubling and that "there is no formula that can tell us where to stop."

Coincidentally, Alan Wolfe summarized John Stuart Mill's view in the same issue: "The purpose of liberty is not to give us what we want but to help us grow so that we can best understand our wants" ("The Forgotten Philosopher," The Chronicle Review). Let us hope that the "new paternalism" does not end up stifling such human growth. In understanding our wants, we get to know ourselves. If someone else is always nudging us in the right direction, we will never figure anything out on our own.

Cyril Morong Associate Professor of Economics San Antonio College San Antonio

---

http://chronicle.com Section: The Chronicle Review Volume 54, Issue 39, Page B27"