Democrats Revive a Jimmy Carter Tax Mistake on ‘Windfall’ Profits

They want to reduce the price incentive to boost oil and gas production.

WSJ editorial. Excerpt:

"U.S. producers have benefited from higher prices caused by the war, but much less than the left claims. Some frackers began pulling back rigs last year as prices fell below what they needed to break even on their investments. Producer margins last year were squeezed by inflation, higher interest rates and tariffs.

The price of Brent crude has been bouncing around north of $100 a barrel, though U.S. shale blends trade at a steep discount in part because they are more costly to refine. At a Brent price of $112 under the Whitehouse-Khanna bill, the government would extract $22 in tax for every barrel sold. That’s more than what some producers have been earning in profit.

Higher prices enable companies to boost supply. Taxing production does the opposite. The short-lived U.S. experiment with a windfall oil profits tax from 1980 to 1988 reduced domestic production and resulted in 80% less tax revenue than projected. Congress finally repealed the tax because it made the U.S. more dependent on foreign oil."