skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Fossil fuel protesters are mostly clueless about how much those low-cost fuels impact and improve their lives
From Mark Perry.
"The Austin American-Statesman reported a few week ago that “Activists say Austin plan for 65% renewable energy isn’t enough“:
More than 100 people rallied at City Hall to protest an
Austin Energy power generation plan they think does not go far enough to
end the use of fossil fuels to power the city. The plan actually
increases the city’s renewable energy goal from 55% to 65% of the power
generated by 2027 for the city, with a possibility of later upping that
goal to 75% renewables. However, dozens of people clad in green T-shirts
and outfits were calling for Austin to end all fossil fuel use for
generating power.
“It doesn’t go far enough,” said Bob Hendrix, one of dozens signed up
to speak against accepting the utility’s power generation plan. “I want
to have more about climate justice renewables and early retirement of
fossil resources.”
An Austin Energy spokesman said that pushing to 100% renewable energy
would cause rate hikes to electric bills for Austin Energy customers. A
presentation from the utility showed that under current renewable
goals, energy rates are expected to increase up to 11% because renewable
energy tends to cost more. Pushing that renewable goal to 75% could
increase electricity bills by 13.5%. The utility didn’t have an estimate
for what having 100% renewable energy would do to residents’
electricity bills.
Here’s David Blackmon’s response in his Forbes article “Do Fossil Fuel Protesters Know How Much Those Fuels Impact Their Lives?“:
My first thought upon seeing the group of protesters was
to wonder how many of them drove to the site of the protest in
gasoline-powered cars, which make up about 99% of automobile fleet in
Texas? I wondered further if any of them understand that many of the
components in the cars they drive – even Teslas – are made from
petroleum-derived products?
Many in the group were wearing sneakers. I can’t help wondering if
they know that those shoes are in part made from petroleum products?
Some carried backpacks – do they know that parts of many such items are
to some extent made from petroleum products?
It was a prosperous-looking bunch, most of whom no doubt practice
sound dental hygiene. I couldn’t help wondering if they know there’s a
very good chance their toothpaste – and their toothbrush, for that
matter – is largely derived from petroleum? I wonder if the women among
the group realize that their makeup and lipsticks are most likely
derived from petroleum as well?
Many in the group were carrying the latest in cellular technology. I
wonder if any of them understand that many of the components that make
up their iPhones and Samsung Galaxies are derived from petroleum
products? What about the elastic that holds up their underwear, or the
frames of their glasses? Do any of these protesters understand that
those are derived from petroleum products? I wonder if they understand
that these products cannot be replaced with windmills or solar panels?
Some in the group were consuming bottled water. I couldn’t help
wondering if they know how those bottles are made. Speaking of water, I
wonder as well if they know that the water that comes into their homes
is almost certainly pumped there by pumps powered by gasoline or natural
gas? And speaking of their homes, I wonder how many of these protesters
cook their meals on natural-gas stoves or heat their homes and water
with natural gas appliances?
No doubt many of the protesters own televisions. I wonder how many of
them know that a significant portion of their TVs are made from
petroleum products? Or that the expensive cables that produce the
picture are insulated by products derived from oil? Or that almost half
of the electricity generated in Texas is generated by natural gas, and
that that share is destined to grow as some of the old coal-fired plants
in the state are retired in the coming years?
Speaking of power plants, I wonder if any of these protesters are
aware of the fact that the United States today has reduced its carbon
emissions to levels not seen since 1992 (see chart above)? That our
country far and away leads the globe in reduction of greenhouse gases,
without being a participant in the Paris Accords or in any other global
emissions agreement? I wonder if any of them understand that the main
reason for this is because, over the last decade, we have replaced a
large number of coal-burning power plants with natural gas capacity?
I wondered if any of them understand that, without the fossil fuels
they demonized at Austin’s city hall on Friday, they’d be paying a lot
more in taxes [and much higher energy costs] than they do today? None
of the reporters present thought to ask any of these questions, so the
answers will remain forever unknown. The older people in that group don’t even have that excuse.
MP: Although David Blackmon was responding
specifically to the Austin protesters, his comments are generally
relevant for any of the millions of anti-fossil fuel Americans who
support high-cost, unreliable renewable energies that will impoverish us
if their use is artificially increased by government mandates, over
low-cost dependable fossil fuel energy sources. I’m sure that almost
none of the green activists or renewable energy supporters have any idea
how much low-cost fossil fuels, and the products derived from them,
contribute to their enviable standard of living that is higher now in
America than any time in history for the average person. And even if
solar and wind energy were to become so cost-competitive that we could
someday generate 100% of our electric power with renewables (without
subsidies), we will still rely on fossil fuels for the many products
derived from them including plastic, components for electronics,
footwear, makeup, elastic, eyeglass frames, paint, tires, deodorant,
dyes, shampoo, bandages, luggage, candles, movie film, soap, insect
repellent, glues/epoxies, linoleum, perfumes, roofing, umbrellas, food
preservatives, vitamin capsules, etc.
See more of a partial list of 144 products made from petroleum here, there are actually 6,000 consumer and industrial products made from petroleum."
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.